Did God Create Man or Did Man Create God?

“There are more things in Heaven and Earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy.”  William Shakespeare, Hamlet

The Bible is often cited as the most-read book in the world (at 5 billion estimated printed copies), but I suspect a significantly lower number have read chapter and verse in its entirety. Once you get past Genesis, it gets a little dry until the smiting, pillaging, and slave-taking ramp up, and Revelation is a bit like a Salvador Dali painting come to life. But there are passages like Ecclesiastes that are sheer joy, especially the adapted version set to music by Pete Seeger and made famous by The Byrds.

Yet, I believe people often claim to have read the Bible as a sign of their piety without actually reading it. All they are fooling is themselves.

But out of curiosity, I Googled the question, “What is the most-read book in the world?”

The top 6  are (with estimated copies in parenthesis)

  1. The Bible (5 billion)
  2. The Quoran (3 Billion)
  3. Quotations of Chairman Mao Tse-Tung aka: The Little Red Book (800 million)
  4. Harry Potter Series (500 million)
  5. Lord of the Rings (150 million)
  6. The Alchemist (150 million)

Now, one might argue the first three have such large numbers because they were forced on people, perhaps after the church got over the shock and heresy of the Bible being translated and distributed into the vernacular, but I digress. And why Mao forced the book on millions and then killed them is a mystery.

So why has religion held sway over humanity for so long? From where did the concept of a deity arise?

Long before the advent of written language, humans shared stories around the fire by telling them to each other. The stories traveled only as far as legs could carry the storytellers and they changed with each telling. But where did the inspiration come from for these tales?

They looked up into the night sky and saw things they could not understand let alone explain. Their experience taught them everything came from something else, so the night sky, filled with inexplicable wandering points of light, vast stretches of color, and balls of fire slashing across the sky had to arise from somewhere. Thus they needed an omnipotent being.

Thunder, lightning, flaring objects we now know as comets, nova, and supernova were the angry reaction to displeasing actions by humans.  

They created the gods, and kept creating them to fill the holes in their understanding, more than 4000 so far.

With man’s communication sophistication increasing, with the advent of written language, with the expansion of territory, distance and frequency of travel, the stories, in all their variety and subtle variations, went with them.

New gods arose to explain new experiences. Battles between factions proved the superiority of the victors’s god over the defeated worshipers of a different deity.

God filled the gap of things we could not explain or control.

And then, as is inevitable, some humans discovered they could dominate others by having a connection to these gods not available to others. The priests and religious leaders were a natural result of the daily interaction with gods.

Humans needed to understand what their god(s) wanted, prophets arose to interpret and proselytize the message.

Those who worshiped other gods were heathens and the enemy of the one true god.

Like the most popular books in the world, there was a whole spectrum of religious doctrines gaining various levels of popularity.

Christianity became successful because the technology of communication underwent an exponential increase. The success of the Roman Empire built the foundation for it’s own demise and the rise of Christanity.

But where Rome did not tread, a different approach to the Abrahamic religions arose. Judaism survived on the periphery of Rome, Islam came into dominance in the area where Eastern Christianity, after the schism with Rome, failed to exert full dominance.

Why does this matter?

Because we face a tidal wave of religious fundamentalism striving to exert itself over the increasing secular world.

We are facing a revival of religion-driven policies trying to regain their once dominant positon within government and over secular life because we are somehow disinclined to question the origin and validity of any faith.

We support a person’s right to practice any faith they choose (except human sacrifice, we reserve that practice for the governments of China, Iran, Saudi Arabia, and the United States.)

But why does our acceptance of this right necessarily imply any acceptance of the validity or factual basis for the existence of these deities?

If one wants to argue in favor or against a policy based on the teachings of a religious doctrine inspired or handed down by an omnipotent being, shouldn’t the first step be to establish this being actually exists?

Once one comes to terms with the uncertainty and murkiness of religious origins, one recognizes the danger in blindly accepting any argument based on such faith.

We don’t need any religion to be moral.

We don’t need to pick and choose our policies based on esoteric writings of uncertain veracity.

Religion can, perhaps, offer us a path to understanding our place in the universe, but it fails miserably in explaining how we got here. I would submit that religious differences are the single most deadly cause of strife in the world since the first Neanderthals (who had ceremonies and burial rites) or Homo Sapiens disagreed over the proper way to appease their gods.

So look up in the sky and be inspired by the beauty of nature,

Keep your faith in any manner you choose.

Embrace the universal rule of “Do unto others…” (first espoused long before the concept of Judaism or Christianity in “The Eloquent Peasant,” dating back to the Middle Kingdom (c. 2040-1650 BCE)

And we need remember that dominance or holding a majority over others does not confer validity to one’s belief nor prove the other inferior.

One thought on “Did God Create Man or Did Man Create God?

  1. Joe: ‘If one wants to argue in favor or against a policy based on the teachings of a religious doctrine inspired or handed down by an omnipotent being, shouldn’t the first step be to establish this being actually exists?’

    Well my friend you are all over the waterfront in this treatise. Where to begin? You make a valid point that organized religion has done great damage over time. The Spanish Inquisition is one of many tragic examples. It is always dangerous when any religion demands allegiance.

    This is one reason James Madison and a Baptist delegate from Virginia named John Leland (the brains behind John was his wife Sally), who championed the first amendment to the Constitution, separating church and state (that the church will not impose its will on the state nor the state on the church).

    Of course what we are seeing once again, is the rise of those who refute this separation. The imbedding of White Christian Nationalists and Christian Nativists in the GOP, who seek to return America to being a Christian nation (which historically it never was.). Washington, Jefferson, Franklin were close to the fringe if not beyond the bounds of Christianity. They had no patience for those who sought to impose religion on others!

    Joe as you point out ,this religious arrogance, most often seen in fundamentalism whether it be Islamic, Christian, Jewish, Hindu etc. is a great danger. As fundamentalists insist that there is only one way to believe and live.

    Trump who couldn’t find his way through the Bible with a flashlight, is quick to raise up the mantle of White Christian Nationalism and the racism that fuels it….because it serves his purpose of more and more power. Historically, this isn’t new. As theologian and satirist Anne Lamott writes: ‘If God hates the same people you do, rest assured you’ve created God in your own image’….Truth!

    However this doesn’t mean that the negatives of faith outweigh the positives….Islam in mid centuries provide world class mathematics and science. Christians built hospitals, universities, promoted the Social Gospel (worker rights and chid labor laws in the 1900s) and the list goes on.

    So I would say that religions which try to make sense of the world and offer guidance for how to live well, isn’t inherently the problem. To the question ‘can it be established that God exists?’ The answer is no and yes,

    As a person of faith, I can tell you that my faith is first and foremost based on a ‘felt experience’ of a loving God. I can’t measure, quantify or prove to you that this is true. I can only say that for ME, the presence of God is the most real thing that I know. My faith is not based so much on dogma, rather, on experience. What the Celts call a ‘thin place’….moments (in nature, or holding my child for the first time, or, as with you Joe, looking up into the sky at night.) These for ME are holy moments. Moments when I feel close to that great, mysterious, creative force that brought the cosmos into being….and, you and me.

    Such moments are worthy of wonder and awe and gratitude. Some call this religion, spirituality. Meister Eckhart the German monk and mystic of the middle age said, ‘if the only prayer you offer is thank you, that is enough’. To that I say, ‘amen’! Joe, thanks as always for stirring the pot…it gets us thinking.

    Like

Leave a reply to Kent Harrop Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.