Joe Broadmeadow

Author · Retired Police Captain

The Sky Is Not a Budget Line

By Joe Broadmeadow

Abstract colorful geometric streams converging at a bright central point

Washington always finds money for what it calls urgent. This year it found plenty for a foreign war and for a tax law that gives up trillions in revenue.

It has been far slower to pay for the system that keeps airliners separated over our heads.

Start with air traffic control.

FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford told lawmakers that Phase One of the modernization will cost $16 billion. Congress provided $12.5 billion, and the agency will cover the $3.5 billion difference itself.

The Government Accountability Office found a larger problem than the shortfall. The FAA has no reliable lifecycle cost estimate and no integrated master schedule for the whole effort. Nobody can yet say what the complete project will cost or when it will finish.

The Iran war has produced its own uncertainty.

The Pentagon reports spending more than $47 billion—more than 25 percent above the $37.5 billion estimate Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth gave in July. Another $29 billion is projected to replace munitions, and more than $6 billion for lost equipment and aircraft. Those projections do not clearly include repairs to bases hit by Iranian missiles and drones.

A government still fighting a war should be able to tell taxpayers the full cost, and it has not.

The tax side of the ledger is larger still.

The Congressional Budget Office estimates that the 2025 tax law adds $3.4 trillion to deficits over a decade. The tax cuts total roughly $3.75 trillion. Congress offsets part of that with roughly $1.3 trillion in cuts to other programs, mainly Medicaid and food assistance.

The country is asked to trim health coverage and food aid so that higher earners and businesses keep more of their income, while the air traffic system waits for funding.

Put the numbers side by side. The $3.4 trillion is about 200 times the FAA’s Phase One cost. The $47 billion already spent on the war is about 1.4 percent of that deficit figure.

Priorities are not an abstraction. They show up in the ledger.

The strongest case for the other side deserves a hearing. Supporters of the tax law argue that the CBO’s static scoring ignores the growth that lower rates can produce, and that Republican leaders say federal revenues have outpaced CBO forecasts in the past.

They point to tariff revenue as a second offset. Defense officials would respond that war costs are hard to forecast, and that munitions replacement is a real security expense, not waste. Some budget analysts would add that the FAA’s $16 billion is a near-term commitment that Congress and the agency have already accepted, and that a lifecycle estimate can be produced without halting work.

Each of these claims has some support, and each deserves a direct answer rather than dismissal.

The answer starts with the tariffs. The CBO’s tariff estimate was tentative, and tariff revenue has moved with trade policy. Asking the public to accept a deficit on the promise of future growth or tariff income is a wager, not a budget.

Revenue history gives little comfort.

The Center for American Progress notes that federal revenue came in at 16.5 percent of GDP in 2023, below the 18.0 percent the CBO projected before the 2017 cuts. Supporters reply that revenue has beaten forecasts in other years. Both sides can cite numbers, which is exactly why Congress should demand better ones.

On defense, the honest answer is that a war’s cost should be reported in full precisely because it is a security expense. Taxpayers can support necessary spending and still deserve a complete accounting.

Lawmakers should do three things.

They should require the FAA to publish a complete lifecycle cost estimate and schedule before releasing more money. They should require the Pentagon to report the full cost of the Iran war, including base repairs and replacement equipment, on a regular public schedule. And they should pair every future tax cut with an offset that is scored honestly and debated in public.

The air traffic controllers who guide planes through crowded skies cannot revise their instructions to aircraft after the fact. Neither should the people who write our budgets.

Joe Broadmeadow

About the author

Joe Broadmeadow is a retired East Providence, Rhode Island, police captain, the author of the Josh Williams and Hawk Bennett crime novels, and the founder of JEBWizard Creative Media. See the books →

Previous:

Leave a Reply